What’s in a word? ‘Smart’, ‘eco’ or ‘future’ cities? Around the world, numerous city initiatives have sprung up in recent years to signal their engagement with sustainable development and global climate change action. But what is the difference between these and other city labels? Are some more important than others? And how will they develop in the coming 50 years?
Scottish and Dutch academics have carried out a global study across 35 different city labels revealing that the term ‘sustainable city’ has been the most popular and overarching one in policy and academic research until five years ago. However, the ‘smart city’ has surged forward in the last five years, as cities use digital technologies and big data to make their metropolitan areas more efficient with their resources. The authors advise urban planners and policymakers to develop awareness of the connections between these various city labels and their respective meanings to maximize the positive impact of their policy interventions
The academics – from the University of Glasgow and Delft University of Technology & Erasmus University Rotterdam in the Netherlands – have carried out a comprehensive analysis of over 11,000 scientific articles to reveal insights in how urban sustainability approaches have evolved over the past 30 years and are likely to develop in the coming 50 years. Some 35 city labels have been identified and used including ‘resilient city’, ‘eco city’, ‘liveable city’, ‘regenerative city’ and ‘learning city’. ‘Smart city’ takes the lion’s share – 46% - of the total research output over the last 30 years.
Relating different aspects of sustainability
The academics study - Past, present, future: engagement with sustainable urban development through 35 city labels in the scientific literature 1990-2019 - advises cities to make essential connections between different aspects of sustainable development, based on a multi-dimensional mapping which relates e.g. ‘liveable’ to ‘ecological’ and ‘creative’ to ‘smart’ urban development.
Creating stronger links between Sustainable Development Goals
The report’s authors - Dr Daan Schraven (TU Delft); Professor Simon Joss (University of Glasgow) and Professor Martin de Jong (Erasmus University Rotterdam) - said:
“The findings demonstrate how urban sustainable development has different connotations and implications for different cities and these various aspects are expressed through the choice of different city labels. Hence, we can use this in policy to create stronger links between Sustainable Development Goal 11 on cities with the other 16 SDGs to help responding to the known challenge that there is often a trade-off between the different goals.
We hope that our study can also benefit urban practitioners by giving them information on the best way forward for their future research, policy and practice to help global cities tackle climate change action. Equally we also hope, as we move towards COP26 summit of world leaders in Glasgow later this year, that our research can help inform and support the conversation and debate on cities and sustainability.”
Cities are key in tackling climate change
Cities’ critical contribution to achieving climate action has been acknowledged in the United National Sustainable Development Goals. Their importance will remain key to the climate change agenda especially as cities and metropolitan areas are now responsible for 70% of global carbon emissions and over 60% of the world’s resource use.
The Scottish and Dutch study, the most comprehensive analysis of all peer-reviewed scientific literature from 1990 to 2019 carried out to date, also reveals insights into the evolution of sustainable urbanism. It has revealed a significant rise in research output in the last three decades, particularly over the last 10 years, on sustainability and cities.
This work has also allowed the academics to forecast and growth modelling to predict likely future developments in sustainable urbanism policy and practice. The research also found that while the labels have distinctive characteristics, they are related and linked via a network of global work on urban sustainability by cities, metropolitan areas, and academic research.
- Professor
- More information
The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) were born at the United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development in Rio de Janeiro in 2012. The objective was to produce a set of universal goals that meet the urgent environmental, political and economic challenges facing our world. The SDG 11 sets out an international recognition of cities’ critical contribution towards sustainability, but also the broad approach pursued: ‘make cities inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable”.
Dutch participation in this study was on behalf of the Erasmus Initiative for the Dynamics of Inclusive Prosperity (DoIP) and its NWO-NSFC research programme Inclusive Wise-Waste Cities (IWWC). DoIP and IWWC collaborate closely with the institute Resilient Delta, a research and education partnership between Erasmus University Rotterdam, Erasmus MC and Delft University of Technology which designs and integrates its sustainable urban development solutions and technologies in the heart of the Rotterdam delta.
Scottish participation in this study was on behalf of the Urban Big Data Centre, with grant funding from the UK's Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC).
